If you are of a nervous disposition OR a needle tatter DO not read further! Well, perhaps you ought as it isn't 'all bad'!!!!! If you do read then I hope you'll read to the end - before you fall asleep!!!
I took a trip to the dark side the other day - you know me and know my opinion on needle tatting from the past. But, I realised after several conversations with needle tatters (particularly Barb) that the needle tatting I self taught myself back in the 70's with the Jiffy needles (courtesy of the Morins) was different to the needle tatting being done nowadays. Takes time for the penny to drop with me!!!
My opinion about needle tatting is based on the fact that it's not traditional -
here is a link which gives the history of tatting on Wikipedia. I have seen one very old published item (1917) showing that a needle can be used but it does make me wonder why it was never adopted and developed like shuttle tatting. I think this is the piece I remember seeing - below.
After yet another ‘chat’ with Barb she pointed out that (like the Jiffy needle method) this is an antiquated method (I hadn’t looked at it closely – just used it as an illustration of when the use of a needle was first seen - probably) and again is probably the reason that the ‘modern’ needle tatting has evolved.
Anyway after these conversations I felt curious enough to try it for myself. Bearing in mind I've had a set of the new sorts of needles (after Jiffy) which I bought before internet ordering was available from Handy Hands and which has remained unopened until a few days ago - you can see my interest in this skill - nil!!!
So, digging around in my tatting cupboard the other day I found this ancient (but new!) set of needles!! Still unopened. A matter of an hour or so later I'd got the 'hang' of this technique. I don't mind the wieldy and (definitely not pretty!) needle or the fact that you have to be careful you don't sit on it but what really bugged me (and I couldn't get it any better - is the 'padded' look of the finished piece. I read all the instructions and got the right sized needle for the right thickness of thread. I tightened my stitches up real snug on the needle and they looked beautiful. I slid them off and there they were - all floppy and limp. I also quickly got into a mess with the long length of thread needed but fortunately the phone didn't ring and nobody came to the door - I only got a tangle once!!!
Anyway, the needles were relegated to the cupboard again for a few days by which time I'd given it more thought and decided to have another 'go'!!!!
This time I thought I'd do a comparison and was surprised to find that the needle tatted and shuttle tatted pieces both came out the same size. That DID surprise me. BUT the needle tatted one is still floppy and the 'stitches' do not hug the core thread as in a shuttle piece. On the left is the needle version and the right is the shuttle.
Now, to summarise my excursion to the dark side (which turned out to be not so dark!).
I can now say that the although the finished item is ALMOST as good as shuttle tatting - it doesn't quite 'make it' for me as it certainly doesn't give a crisp finish.
The needles are NOT pretty!!!
The length of thread needed that lies in the lap is extremely annoying and tangles easily - in my second attempt I got into an even worse tangle as there was more thread. I'm not sure which would be worse - so much dangly thread or forever joining in new!!!
Finally - why on this planet would anybody want to learn something that is harder to learn than using a shuttle with a poorer result!! I can't see how this is easy to carry around with you when that length of thread is going to have to be put in a bag!
My final word is still that this side line of the craft should not be called tatting. In fact ALL tatting SHOULD in my opinion be defined by the way it is made. We have 'bobbin' lace, 'needle' lace, 'knitted' lace, 'tape' lace and 'machine' lace so why shouldn't we define these two as 'shuttle' tatting and 'needle' tatting every time it's mentioned. Honestly it's only fair to the person reading it to be given the information that there are two ways of getting there.
BACK TO MY SHUTTLES - WHOOOPEEEEE.